E-mail this article to
yourself or a friend.
Enter address:


India Rejects US GM Foodaid and GM Corn-soya Blend Imports

(Sunday, March 9, 2003 -- CropChoice news) --

(Times News Network, NEW DELHI): At the end of a marathon four-hour meeting, the genetic engineering approval committee (GEAC) on Thursday rejected the US case for permitting import of corn-soya blend suspected to contain genetically-modified corn and meant for government aid schemes.

"They were unable to satisfy our queries,'' said one official. GEAC wanted a certificate from the US and the aid agencies involved, CARE and Catholic Relief Services, that each consignment of corn-soya blend brought in as food aid would not contain StarLink, a variety of corn banned for human consumption.

The thrust of the US argument was that food is evaluated for safety in the US and Americans consume the same varieties but certification is against the country's policy of not differentiating between GM and non-GM crops.

In the absence of a certificate, ruled the inter-ministerial GEAC, it saw no reason to review its November decision to refuse import of corn-soya blend which might contain obsolete or banned varieties of GM corn. CARE and CRS had initially applied for permission to import a total of 23,000 metric tonnes of corn-soya blend.

On Thursday, for the second time, ``serious apprehensions'' were voiced, particularly since StarLink corn is supposed to have surfaced in a recent shipment from the US to Japan. The Indian Council of Medical Research representative warned about long-term exposure to corn-soya blend containing GM corn, particularly since food aid is meant for people already vulnerable.ICMR also cautioned that there was no mechanism for post-aid disbursement surveillance. Nobody, quite simply, would know what really happens. But given the keenness with which this case has been pursued at the official and political level, GEAC heard USAID, CARE and CRS officials for about an hour and a half. A power-point presentation led them through the US process for approval of GM crops, the varieties approved for human or animal consumption, the results of food safety evaluations, the names of beneficiary organisations and arrangements for monitoring health impacts,both in the US and under the Integrated Child Development Scheme.

Through it all, three problem points remained. One, the US does not believe in segregation or in differentiating between GM and non-GM crops so there is no question of certification - a policy which has also led to political duels between the US and countries in Europe and Africa.

Two, it is understood, the US does not voluntarily disclose whether a food aid consignment contains GM ingredients or not. Indian rules, however, do demand that the importing agency and the exporting country declare this. Three, despite assurances that food aid consignments so far have tested negative for StarLink and that the probability is minimal, officials could not deny the possibility of obsolete varieties of corn creeping into a consignment undetected ^ there is a basic threshold level for detection.

StarLink registration, it is said, was withdrawn voluntarily in 2000. Just 0.4 per cent of the corn area was apparently under Starlink but it created a major controversy in the US when traces of this corn surfaced in tacos there.

GEAC Once Again Says `No' To Proposed GM Corn-Soya Blend Imports

(Financial Express, New Delhi, March 6 )

The Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC) once again rejected the request made by CARE-India and the Catholic Relief Services (CRS) to allow them to import genetically modified (GM) corn-soya blend from US for distribution amongst the poor.

Earlier the GEAC under the then chairmanship of AM Gokhale had said `No' to the request made by CARE-India and CRS. The GEAC which met for the first time after Ms Sushama Choudhary took over as new chairperson re-opened the issue and deliberated over it for three-and-half hours on Thursday and finally came to the conclusion "there is no need to revise the earlier decision taken by the GEAC".

The Care-India proposed to import 15,000 tonne of GM Corn-soya blend and the CRS about 8,000 tonne. Usually the USAID gives food to these agencies free of cost.

On Thursday while arriving at the decision the GEAC said "as the concerned parties are not willing to certify that the said consignment would not contain any traces of Starlink Corn or any other GM traces hazardous to human health, the committee, under circumstances, is unable to permit such imports."

In the Thursday's meeting the repreesentatives from Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) raised the issue of the possibility of a large section of the vulnerable population falling prey to health hazards by consuming such GM foods. They pointed out that in the recent past there were reports of traces of Starlink Corn slipping into US food consignments to Japan, South Korea and Australia and that the governments in these countries have taken stern steps to protect their population.